My Rating: 3 hearts
Thoughts
on the Novel: Since I love fantasy and haven’t read a story about trolls yet, I was
really looking forward to reading Danielle L. Jensen’s Stolen Songbird. Although
the book ultimately didn’t live up to my expectations, it still turned out to
be a decent read.
For me to enjoy a fantasy thoroughly, it’s
crucial that I don’t question the worldbuilding. In Stolen Songbird, I was
content to accept a world where trolls existed, were cursed to live under a
mountain, and traded with some humans who knew about them. I wasn’t so
satisfied with the worldbuilding though once it became clear that the story was
set on Earth because very little explanation was provided about the human world
outside Trollus. We also don’t find out where Trollus is situated on Earth.
Personally, if a fantasy involves creatures other than faeries, I prefer that it be set in a fictional world.
Another thing that wasn’t well explained
was Tristan’s physical appearance. According to the novel, all the royal trolls
are physically disfigured due to inbreeding. Yet the crown prince of the trolls is the most handsome “man” that Cecile
has ever seen! I hope there’s a deeper reasoning behind the decision to not
have Tristan suffering from disfiguration other than the fact that it’s easier
for both Cecile and the reader to fall in love with a good-looking troll than
an scary-looking one.
Speaking of Cecile, even though her
situation seemed impossible, I liked that she continued trying to find ways out
of Trollus … at least until she realized that she was in love with Tristan. I thought the transition from hate to love was a bit too sudden, and wasn’t very
pleased that Cecile was the one who had to sacrifice everything – and was willing to do so – to
live with Tristan (under a mountain!).
Stolen Songbird will be released by Strange
Chemistry on April 1, 2014.
In exchange for an honest review, this book was received from the publisher (Strange Chemistry) for free via NetGalley.
original image from thegate.ca |
Not sure about this one, Z. The reviews have been all over the place. Frankly reading about trolls doesn't sound all that appealing to me, maybe because I immediately think of those creepy dolls that were the fad in the 90s. Lol, anyways I'll keep an eye on this one but I won't pick it up soon. Sorry it didn't meet your expectations!
ReplyDeleteAwww too bad Z! I have my review of this one going up tomorrow and I adored it, but you do make some good points. I tend to be perfectly content with things like the hero being beautiful even when most of his kind have some kind of disfigurement. I just never question things like that, not sure why. Glad it was still a decent read for you though!
ReplyDeleteSounds like there are a lot of holes in the worldbuilding. Its the same for me where if I'm reading a story and its set of Earth I would at least like to know which part of the world its set in.
ReplyDeleteHmm yeah, I know what you mean about needing good world building in my fantasies. Sometimes I can let it pass if I like everything else about the book, but it's hard wen you have other issues, as well. I'm curious about the whole troll thing though, so I think I may still try this one out sometime.
ReplyDeleteI think this is the first review I've read that wasn't overwhelmingly positive, so it's actually kind of good to have tempered expectations. I'm not always as huge a stickler for world-building if there are other things I enjoy, though, so I'm still curious about this one. Thanks for the honest review.
ReplyDeleteWendy @ The Midnight Garden
Aw, too bad about the world building. I like it when there is explanation and background to a world because I WANT it to make sense, you know? Sounds like a fairly good read other than that.
ReplyDeleteI keep seeing this one everywhere! Anyway, I really like the enemies-turned-lovers trope but since you also mentioned "sudden," I'll have to reconsider.
ReplyDelete