My Rating: 3 hearts
Thoughts
on the Novel: Anne Blankman’s Prisoner of Night and Fog was a debut that
I had been looking forward to reading since last year. Sadly, while I did think
it was a decent read, I struggled to connect with the story for a number of
reasons.
First, I had an issue with how fast
Gretchen believed everything that she was told by Daniel. I mean, it just seemed
like one minute she was a staunch National Socialist and the next minute she
was all confused because some stranger – who also happened to be a Jew and
therefore someone she would be biased to not believe – tells her that her
father was murdered! Oh, and how convenient that Gretchen held on to the shirt
that her father was wearing when he was killed so that the plot could be moved
along!
Another element of the story that I
didn’t like was the romance. Although it was nice that Gretchen and Daniel’s
relationship started off with them hesitant to trust each other, I thought it
progressed rather quickly. Considering that Gretchen viewed Jews as subhuman initially,
I was rather surprised, for example, that Daniel invited someone that Hitler
favoured into the house he shared with his cousins after just three interactions!
Lastly, I found most of the
secondary characters to be very flat. Although I thought Prisoner of Night and
Fog was well-researched, the characters from the Nazi party just came
off like names with little personality attached to them. Even Hitler seemed like
a two-dimensional character, which I thought was very unfortunate.
Prisoner of Night and Fog was
released on April 22, 2014 by Balzer + Bray.
Comments
About the Cover: I love the foggy background as it makes the model’s face
in the foreground really stand out. It may be just me, but I think her eyes
look a little haunted, which reflects the title nicely.
In exchange for an honest review, this book was received from the publisher (HarperCollins) for free via Edelweiss.
Huh, I've read nothing but rave reviews for this one and but your review does give me some pause. I think I will stick pick this one up just to see what make this one a captivating read for others.
ReplyDeleteYep, I felt pretty much the same way about this one. Gave it about the same rating, too. The romance-yes! All of the sudden they went from "enemies" to kissing, leaving me wondering if I missed something. Haha, the shirt thing WAS pretty convenient.. plus the fact she was able to figure out the thing about the powder almost out of nowhere... Great review though :)
ReplyDeleteWell, when you put it that way, this one doesn't seem too realistic! And it always bothers me when authors rely on conveniences instead of doing something that might take more work, but makes a lot more sense! I do think this one has a unique premise, as I've never seen that point of view before, but I wish it had been executed better.
ReplyDeleteSorry this one didn't work too well for you Z! Sounds like you really have to suspend disbelief with this one going in, and sometimes I'm able to do that just fine. Other times it's more of a struggle, but now that I know I need to do that I think this story will go over better for me. Thanks for your thoughts!
ReplyDeleteHeard many good things about Prisoner of Night and Fog and I was really hoping this could be something like The Book Thief for people. Because I absolutely loved that book. Sorry to hear that Prisoner of Night and Fog wasn't as convincing as one would hope. The romance is always very important to me and I'm really not sure if this book is something for me when Gretchen acts like that, against her own beliefs just after a few chapters. Thanks for your honest review!:)
ReplyDelete