My Rating: 2.5 hearts
Thoughts
on the Novel: With its promise of thieves and assassins and the author
mentioning on Goodreads that one of her inspirations is Tamora Pierce’s
The Song of the Lioness quartet, Midnight Thief by Livia Blackburne was a novel that
I couldn’t wait to get my hands on. Sadly, the writing was simplistic and the
characters left little impression.
To me, it felt like there was a lot
of telling rather than showing going on in Midnight Thief. As well, more description would definitely have helped to make the setting and characters
more vivid. That being said, Midnight Thief was a breezy
read, and I can easily see it appeal to older MG readers.
Like the setting, the characters
were also pretty flat. The story is narrated through both Kyra and Tristam’s points
of view, but I never found the switches in narration to be seamless. In fact,
Tristam’s narration was very unexpected and abrupt at the beginning because for
the first five chapters, everything was told from Kyra’s perspective. However, I liked Tristam better than Kyra, who joins the Assassins Guild yet objects to
killing (uh, so why join the Assassins Guild
at all?!), but only by a slight margin because both characters were similar in
that they didn’t think too much about the possible consequences of their
actions. Since I couldn’t have cared less about the fate of the characters, I
also ended up not caring if they would get together or not.
Midnight Thief will be released on July 8,
2014 by Disney-Hyperion.
Comments
About the Cover: I love it! The cat looks fierce, and is just daring you to
find out what it’s hiding!
In exchange for an honest review, this book was received from the publisher (Disney Book Group) for free via NetGalley.
I am officially confused, haha. There's been so many mixed reviews of this one, that I've gone from wanting to read to not wanting it. I guess it's just the kind of book you have to try for your self.
ReplyDeleteI'm a bit baffled by Kyra I have to admit - I've read in several reviews that she's against killing, so I can't help but question WHY she would join an assassin's guild. O.o Still, I did enjoy the prequel (which granted Kyra wasn't in), so I'm still a little curious about this one. Thanks for the heads up on a few issues to watch out for though Z!
ReplyDeleteBummer. I was really looking forward to this one. I guess I'll have to lower my expectations when I read it.
ReplyDeleteI have the e-book prequel novella to this one but haven't yet read it. Disappointing to hear that Midnight Thief fails to stand out both in worldbuilding and characterization! (Also, yeah, like Jenny I too am wondering WHY someone would join an assassin's guild if they have a problem with killing. It doesn't explain this??)
ReplyDeleteCould not agree more! I was so disappointed because I really liked the novella. I wish I had read this book about 15 years ago.
ReplyDeleteyea i also didn't love this.. the characters did fall flat and i would have loved more background info on the world. I also didn't really like the supernatural elements that popped up halfway through the book. It is a breezy book though. Great review!
ReplyDelete- Juhina @ Maji Bookshelf
Aww, I'm sorry to see this didn't work out for you! I don't think I'll be having much luck with it either, to be frank, which is a shame as its synopsis seemed to have so much potential. Thanks for such an honest and helpful review, though!
ReplyDeleteYup, definitely a lot of telling in this one. That, combined with the flat, stereotypical characters that make questionable decisions, and the very generalized and lacking any originality setting made this one more of a meh read for me, as well. I think a lot of it was disappointment because it was set up to be so great and I thought for sure I would like it, but the overall execution wasn't great either. Anyways, I liked reading your thoughts here and completely concur with all of them!!
ReplyDeleteThis is the second not so great review I have seen of this book. I am not sure that I'll like it. I find that I get incredibly annoyed at info dumps and telling rather than showing. Nope, this book is not for me.
ReplyDeleteThanks, for the review.