My Rating: 4 hearts
Thoughts
on the Novel: After seeing lots of praise for Hannah Harrington’s debut
novel Saving June and then again for her newest book Speechless, I wondered
what I was missing out on and figured I’d give her sophomore novel a try before
my galley expired. I’m not really fond of stories revolving around selfish,
mean girls so when I first started Speechless and realized Chelsea was one of
those girls who ignores how awful her “best friend” is in order to stay
popular, I speculated how long it
would take before she blurted out the secret mentioned in the synopsis.
Fortunately, not long; and by the end, Harrington’s gradual development of Chelsea’s character had me if not liking Chelsea, at least respecting her.
In my opinion, by far the best thing
about Speechless was Chelsea’s
voice because it was so honest and easy to relate to. Since Chelsea decides to
take a vow of silence – which to me seemed a tad unrealistic because why decide
to stop speaking altogether when you could just as easily make a vow not to
gossip for example – a significant chunk of the book focuses on her thoughts.
Through Chelsea’s
perspective, you realize that, like anybody, she’s flawed and is a myriad of
contradictions – brave, judgmental, determined and self-absorbed yet also vulnerable,
thoughtful and perceptive.
I also liked the secondary
characters. I just wish I could have gotten to see them in a more personal
environment (e.g. in their homes) so that I could learn about them as
characters independent of their interactions with Chelsea at school or work.
Another thing that I would have
liked more time to be spent on was the relationship between Chelsea and Kristen. Since the two stop hanging out after
the awful incident, we don’t really get to see Kristen as anything other than a stereotypical mean girl. At the same time
though, I was okay with the way their relationship was portrayed because there was eventually some sort of resolution
between the two.
Speechless was released in August 2012 by Harlequin Teen.
In exchange for an honest review, this book was received from the publisher (Harlequin Teen) for free via NetGalley.
I'm really not a fan of high school drama and mean girls either so I had initially written off this book, as well. However, I think I could withstand and even enjoy a book where said mean girl has a true character arc. And this one sounds really well done, too. I'm impressed! Hopefully I'll find the time to read this one, thanks!
ReplyDeleteLike you and Aylee, I usually shy away from "mean girl" stories because they just frustrate me to no end, but I've heard such great things about this book and I'm really interested in Chelsea's character development. Despite the few minor drawbacks you mentioned, this book sounds amazing and given that I haven't seen a review below a 4 for it yet, I think it needs to go on the list!
ReplyDeleteLike you I'm not fond of mean girls and the popularity drama, which is why I skipped this one, however, I'm glad that Chelsea became a bit more introspective and seems to have learned how to take the bigger picture in. There's nothing more infuriating when the one characters don't realize that they are participating in the same behavior that they dislike.
ReplyDeleteI have this one here but havent pick it up yet. Near the release date there were so many, so many reviews coming out that I was like... okay, this one has enough buzz so it can wait for later. But hey, I will for sure pick it up because your review is not the only positive one I have read. Actually they have been all pretty good. And like you,I havent read Saving June either. XD I love when I read reviews that talk about the voice of the novel. That's one of the things that will play a BIG role in hooking me to the story or not. SO glad you loved it =D Im IN for this one! moving it up on my pile.
ReplyDeleteWonderful review Zahida <333333
Yay, another fan. :) It always pleases me to see another positive review of this novel... Nicely reviewed and I agree, the simplicity of the cover is actually beautiful!
ReplyDeleteOh I completely thought this was a temporary cover too. I kept wondering why they hadn't released the final cover when we were so close to the release date! :D Ha, I have warmed to its simplicity now though. ;)
ReplyDeleteThis is a great review, Z! I think Harrington's timing at the start was perfect. There's only so much of that mean-girl rubbish I can tolerate before having to put the book away. Thankfully Chelsea started to appeal to me at exactly the right time. :)
Fantastic review Z. This wasn't a book that appealed to me, but I've seen nothing but great reviews for it, and I'm glad to see that you enjoyed it too.
ReplyDelete